“Fall” for these delicious pies through Thanksgiving, Christmas, and all-season long.
by Kayla Garritano
Acorn Farm & Garden Center
What looks like an unassuming shack on a busy street that sells outdoor structures and furniture, also serves as a country store filled with homemade baked goods. Indulge in their freshly baked apple crumble, cherry, and various other pies.
470 Mamaroneck Avenue, Harrison, NY | 914.698.7846
Baked by Susan
Owner Susan started making mud pies as a kid. Fast forward years later, and she’s opened a store full of original family recipes. Her wide variety of pies are made by hand from scratch daily, using local seasonal fruits when possible. Indulge in family favorites meant for the holidays, such as seasonal pecan, cherry almond tart, banana cream, or chocolate cream.
379 S Riverside Avenue, Croton-on-Hudson, NY | 914.862.0874
Fleetwood Pastry Shop
This family-owned and operated bakery reopened in 1997 in Mt Vernon and added a second location in 2024 to cater to all of Westchester. Along with an assortment of traditional pies, they also make a variety for the holidays, including grain and sweet pies, sweet potato, Boston cream, and pizza rustica (a meat pie).
561 Gramatan Avenue, Mount Vernon, NY | 914.667.3434
57 Wheeler Avenue, Pleasantville, NY | 914.303.3636
Galloway’s Bakery
Fred and Marjorie Galloway opened up a luncheonette that sold pie by the slice. The pies were so successful that in 1956, Galloway’s turned into a bakery. Now, customers can enjoy various top crust, cream, crumb, and meringue pies, as well as pecan and seasonal pumpkin, and mince pies.
69 Harney Road, Scarsdale, NY | 914.725.4074
Neri’s Bakery
For over 100 years, the Neri family has strived to deliver the finest and most consistent wholesale and retail products with their state-of-the-art equipment. Specifically in their pie options, you can indulge in their 8 inch and 10 inch pies, all the way from banana cream to apple, to coconut custard, mince meat, and pumpkin.
31-37 Pearl Street, Port Chester, NY | 914.937.3235
Noble Pies
From a small picnic table to a store, baking pies for Thanksgiving to opening throughout the year, the owners were “noble” enough to open their pie business throughout Westchester and beyond. Indulge in both sweet and savory pies, like “Will You Marry Me Cherry” or a chicken pot pie. You can also enjoy a pie in milkshake form.
38 Main Street, Tarrytown, NY | 914.418.5649
Red Barn Bakery
This 100% organic bakery is also vegan and has gluten-free pastries and pies on deck. Along with their fruit pies, gear up for the holiday season with unique selections like apple salted caramel. Artisanal pie fillings include ginger peach, chocolate pecan, and ginger peach.
4 S Astor Street, Irvington, NY | 914.231.7779
Seth Greenberg’s Just Desserts
Seth truly is all about desserts. For the fall, he whips up tasty comfort treats, including a packed apple crumb pie or blueberry, created with a classic butter crust, caramelized apple or unique blueberry filling, topped with cinnamon crumbs. Both can be made in a 7 inch or 9 inch.
1887 Palmer Avenue, Larchmont, NY | 914.630.1807
The Snackery Bake Shop
C.E.O. and owner Sara took her passion for creating unique sweets and treats and turned it into Sara Snacker Cookie Co. in 2008. Opening her storefront, she continues to take classics and turn them into something special. Try her pecan, pumpkin, chocolate pecan, and seasonal apple pie. Can’t decide on just one? Try the famous Quatro- pumpkin, cherry, apple, and pecan all in one!
64 Purchase Street, Rye, NY | 914.481.1636
Topps Bakery
This 80-year-old business offers over 200 handmade baked goods with the goal of catering to the “treasured memories of childhood trips to the local bakery.” For the holidays, enjoy a vast selection of fruit and holiday pies: pumpkin, mixed berry, key lime, cherry, and more!
106 Pondfield Road, Bronxville, NY | 914.337.4258
